Income taxpayers can set off short term capital loss from share sale against long term capital gains: ITAT The decision is a huge relief for stock market investors who often face scrutiny during income tax assessments
In a significant ruling, the Mumbai bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) upheld a taxpayer's right to engage in legitimate tax planning, allowing the set-off of short-term capital losses incurred from the sale of shares against long-term capital gains (LTCGs), according a TOI report. The decision comes as a relief for stock market investors who often face scrutiny during income tax assessments. Tax experts say that the ruling draws a clear distinction between legitimate tax planning and tax evasion.#sr_widget.onDemand p, #stock_pro.onDemand p{font-size: 14px;line-height: 1.28;} .onDemand .live_stock{left:17px;padding:1px 3px 1px 5px;font-size:12px;font-weight:600;line-height:18px;top:9px} #sr_widget.onDemand .sr_desc{margin:0 auto 0;} #sr_widget.onDemand .sr_desc{color: #024d99;margin-top:10px;} #sr_widget.onDemand .crypto .live_stock .lb-icon{8px 6px 5px 3px !important} #sr_widget.crypto.onDemand a.text{border-bottom:1px solid #ccc;padding-bottom:5px;display:block;width:100%} #sr_widget.onDemand .sr_desc .text p, #stock_pro.onDemand .sr_desc .text p{font-size:12px;font-weight:400;} The case is from financial year 2015-16, where the taxpayer, a resident individual, incurred short-term capital loss of Rs 9.1 crore from selling Mindtree shares. The loss was set off against an LTCG of Rs 16.8 crore from the sale of Avendus Capital shares. The income tax assessing officer, however, disallowed the short-term capital losses claim, reclassified it as long-term capital gains, and added it back to the taxpayer's income. The officer argued that the taxpayer exploited a drop in Mindtree’s share price after the announcement of a bonus issue, strategically selling the shares to generate short-term capital loss that could offset the LTCG, a move the officer described as a "colourable device."
Also read | Advance tax payment deadline December 15, 2024 falls on Sunday this time: Can you pay advance income tax on December 16?
The taxpayer filed a return declaring an income of Rs 15.87 crore. During assessment, the income tax officer observed that the taxpayer had earned an LTCG of Rs 16.81 crore from selling 1.23 crore shares of Avendus Capital Pvt Ltd. The taxpayer set off Rs 9.14 crore from the sale of Mindtree shares, which the officer contested. He argued that the bonus announcement caused a significant drop in Mindtree’s share price, and the taxpayer’s sale of the shares to book a loss was a tactic to reduce tax liability by offsetting the LTCG, which is exempt.
In response, the taxpayer appealed to the Commissioner of Appeals, who ruled in her favour, leading the tax department to escalate the matter to the ITAT. The tribunal dismissed the department’s appeal, emphasizing that the taxpayer did not employ any unfair means to reduce her tax liability.
Artificial Intelligence(AI)
Basics of Generative AI: Unveiling Tomorrow's Innovations
By - Metla Sudha Sekhar, IT Specialist and Developer
Office Productivity
Zero to Hero in Microsoft Excel: Complete Excel guide 2024
By - Metla Sudha Sekhar, IT Specialist and Developer
Web Development
A Comprehensive ASP.NET Core MVC 6 Project Guide for 2024
By - Metla Sudha Sekhar, IT Specialist and Developer
Marketing
Digital marketing - Wordpress Website Development
By - Shraddha Somani, Digital Marketing Trainer, Consultant, Strategiest and Subject Matter expert
Finance
A2Z Of Finance: Finance Beginner Course
By - elearnmarkets, Financial Education by StockEdge
Office Productivity
Mastering Microsoft Office: Word, Excel, PowerPoint, and 365
By - Metla Sudha Sekhar, IT Specialist and Developer
Artificial Intelligence(AI)
AI for Everyone: Understanding and Applying the Basics on Artificial Intelligence
By - Ritesh Vajariya, Generative AI Expert
Web Development
Mastering Full Stack Development: From Frontend to Backend Excellence
By - Metla Sudha Sekhar, IT Specialist and Developer
Web Development
JavaScript Essentials: Unlock AI-Driven Insights with ChatGPT
By - Metla Sudha Sekhar, IT Specialist and Developer
Finance
Value and Valuation Masterclass
By - CA Himanshu Jain, Ex McKinsey, Moody's, and PwC, Co - founder, The WallStreet School
Data Science
SQL Server Bootcamp 2024: Transform from Beginner to Pro
By - Metla Sudha Sekhar, IT Specialist and Developer
Finance
Financial Literacy for Non-Finance Executives
By - CA Raja, Chartered Accountant | Financial Management Educator | Former AVP - Credit, SBI
Finance
A2Z Of Money
By - elearnmarkets, Financial Education by StockEdge
Artificial Intelligence(AI)
Collaborative AI Foundations: Working Smarter with Machines
By - Prince Patni, Software Developer (BI, Data Science)
Artificial Intelligence(AI)
Master in Python Language Quickly Using the ChatGPT Open AI
By - Metla Sudha Sekhar, IT Specialist and Developer
Web Development
Master RESTful APIs with Python and Django REST Framework: Web API Development
By - Metla Sudha Sekhar, IT Specialist and Developer
Web Development
Intermediate C++ Skills: Master Pointers, Structures and File Stream
By - Metla Sudha Sekhar, IT Specialist and Developer
Finance
Financial Literacy i.e Lets Crack the Billionaire Code
By - CA Rahul Gupta, CA with 10+ years of experience and Accounting Educator
Design
Canva Magic Write: Ideas to Stunning Slides in No Time
By - Prince Patni, Software Developer (BI, Data Science)
Office Productivity
Microsoft Word Mastery: From Beginner to Expert
By - CA Raj K Agrawal, Chartered Accountant
Entrepreneurship
Crafting a Powerful Startup Value Proposition
By - Dr. Anu Khanchandani, Startup Coach with more than 25 years of experience
Artificial Intelligence(AI)
Tabnine AI Masterclass: Optimize Your Coding Efficiency
By - Metla Sudha Sekhar, IT Specialist and Developer
Data Science
SQL for Data Science along with Data Analytics and Data Visualization
By - Metla Sudha Sekhar, IT Specialist and Developer
Web Development
Django & PostgreSQL Mastery: Build Professional Web Applications
By - Metla Sudha Sekhar, IT Specialist and Developer
Artificial Intelligence(AI)
ChatGPT Mastery from Zero to Hero: The Complete AI Course
By - Metla Sudha Sekhar, IT Specialist and Developer
Strategy
Succession Planning Masterclass
By - Nigel Penny, Global Strategy Advisor: NSP Strategy Facilitation Ltd.
Also read | ITR filing last date FY2023-24: Missed ITR deadline or made mistake in ITR? File a revised, belated return by December 31, 2024
Tax laws allow a short-term capital loss (from shares held for less than 12 months) to be set off against any capital gain, whether short-term or long-term. In contrast, long-term capital losses can only offset long-term gains. The income tax officer’s argument relied on the 1985 Supreme Court ruling in McDowell & Co., which condemned the use of "colourable devices" to evade taxes. The officer claimed the taxpayer timed the sale of Mindtree shares deliberately after the bonus issue announcement to generate short-term capital loss, thereby lowering her tax liability.
However, the ITAT bench, comprising of Vice-President Saktijit Dey and Accountant Member Amarjit Singh, found no evidence to suggest that the transactions were anything but genuine. The tribunal stated that the short-term capital loss incurred by the taxpayer could not be disallowed based solely on accusations of a "colourable device." It concluded that, in the absence of evidence questioning the authenticity of the transactions, the loss resulting from these transactions should be allowed to be set off.
“In our view, the conclusion drawn by the Assessing Officer is wholly irrational and unsustainable. When the transactions relating to purchase and sale of shares are beyond doubt and are not in the nature of sham transaction even there is no such allegation by the Assessing Officer, the short term capital loss derived by the assessee from sale of shares cannot be prevented from being set off against the long term capital gain by alleging adoption of colorable device. There is no requirement under the law that the assessee has to pay more tax. If the assessee arranges her affairs within the legal framework and through legitimate means to reduce its tax liability, the Assessing Officer cannot prevent her from doing so. When there is no evidence on record to doubt the genuineness of the transactions entered into by the assessee, the resultant capital loss derived out of such transaction cannot be disallowed,” the ITAT order stated.
The order further added, “More so, when the Assessing Officer has not expressed any doubt or dispute regarding the nature of loss, being capital. Even, as rightly observed by the learned First Appellate Authority, the Assessing Officer has accepted the computation of short term capital loss made by the assessee. It is further relevant observe, the long term capital gain shown by the assessee on sale of bonus shares of M/s Mindtree Ltd. have been accepted in subsequent assessment year i.e. A.Ys. 2017-18 and 2018-19. That being the factual position emerging on record, we do not find any infirmity in decision of the learned First Appellate Authority. While coming to the aforesaid conclusion, we have drawn support from the decision of Hon’ble Jurisdictional High Court in case of PCIT vs. Cyrus Poonawalla [2018] 100 taxmann.com 227. Accordingly, grounds are dismissed."
The ITAT said there is no requirement under the law for a taxpayer to pay more tax if they arrange their affairs within the legal framework. The tribunal said the taxpayer’s actions were legitimate and conducted within the boundaries of the law, dismissing the Revenue’s appeal. The ITAT also said that the tax authorities later accepted the LTCG from the sale of Mindtree bonus shares in subsequent financial years, further affirming the legitimacy of the taxpayer’s transactions.
#sr_widget.onDemand p, #stock_pro.onDemand p{font-size: 14px;line-height: 1.28;} .onDemand .live_stock{left:17px;padding:1px 3px 1px 5px;font-size:12px;font-weight:600;line-height:18px;top:9px} #sr_widget.onDemand .sr_desc{margin:0 auto 0;} #sr_widget.onDemand .sr_desc{color: #024d99;margin-top:10px;} #sr_widget.onDemand .crypto .live_stock .lb-icon{8px 6px 5px 3px !important} #sr_widget.crypto.onDemand a.text{border-bottom:1px solid #ccc;padding-bottom:5px;display:block;width:100%} #sr_widget.onDemand .sr_desc .text p, #stock_pro.onDemand .sr_desc .text p{font-size:12px;font-weight:400;}
This story originally appeared on: India Times - Author:Faqs of Insurances
